October 16, 2025

If you’re a homeowner in Ireland thinking about putting solar panels on your roof, the decision often comes down to two options: the familiar black or blue solar panels, or the new idea of solar tiles which sit flush to your roof and aim to blend in.

Both generate electricity from daylight, but they take very different approaches to cost, appearance, installation and long-term performance.

For most households, the choice isn’t just technical, it’s personal.

In Ireland, where many homes are older, roofs vary widely (slate, tile, metal, shallow pitches, dormers, terraces), and weather plus planning considerations often influence the right decision more than raw marketing claims.

In this article, we’ll answer the exact questions homeowners ask, explain the trade-offs clearly, and finish with a practical checklist you can use before you sign any contracts.

1. What Exactly Are Solar Panels and Solar Tiles?

Solar panels are discreet modules made from photovoltaic (PV) cells, mounted on your existing roof.

They are the most common way to add solar to your home and are available in a wide range of sizes and performance levels. Installers attach them to a mounting system that is fixed into the roof structure.

Solar tiles (solar roof tiles, BIPV) are designed to replace some or all of the conventional roofing material. Instead of sitting above the roof, they become part of it. They come in different forms, fully replacing tiles or slates in an area, or being hybrid units that visually mimic the roof while producing power. The key idea is integration and aesthetics.

2. Will Solar Tiles Produce as Much Electricity as Panels?

The short answer is: generally no. Solar panels will usually produce more electricity per square meter.

Solar PV panels are optimised for power density and are mounted at an optimal tilt and orientation to maximise yield.

Solar tiles, because they need to match roof geometry and often prioritise appearance, typically have lower power output per square metre. If your roof area is limited and you rely on every kilowatt-hour, panels usually give higher energy returns for the same roof area.

For Irish conditions, panel efficiency and how they’re sited matter more than the raw daylight hours. Install a high-efficiency panel on an optimally angled, unshaded south-facing roof and it will outperform a visually similar area of tiles in most cases.

3. Which Option Costs Less to Buy and Install?

Short answer: solar PV panels are usually cheaper up-front and deliver a lower cost per kilowatt installed.

Manufacturers of solar panels and their components are highly available, the supply chain is mature and installers are experienced.

Solar tiles are less common, often require specialist installers, and may involve reroofing work, all of which increase labour and material costs.

If you factor cost per kW, solar panels generally win.

That said, if your roof already needs replacement and you were planning a reroof anyway, some homeowners choose tiles because the incremental cost difference narrows when combined with roofing work.

Always compare full project costs (roof, scaffolding, labour, electrical works) rather than just the price per tile or per panel.

Read this article to learn more about the cost of solar panels.

4. How Do Aesthetics and Planning Rules Compare?

Solar tiles are designed to blend in, so they may look better, particularly on highly visible roofs. However, being better looking doesn’t automatically mean you won’t need planning permission.

Listed or protected structures, conservation areas, and some planning authorities may have stricter rules.

With solar panels, modern low-profile options are less visually obtrusive than in the past, but they are still attached on top of the roof and more visible.

In Ireland, planning requirements vary by local council and by the nature of your home. For protected properties, you should check with your local planning authority before specifying a product on aesthetics alone.

We will discuss the planning requirements for solar panel installation in a future article.

5. What Roof Types and Conditions Suit Each Option?

Solar panels are well suited to most roofs, whereas tiles are best for reroofs or when roof renewal is already planned.

Solar panels are very flexible, they can be installed on pitched roofs with a variety of coverings (slate, tile, metal sheeting), on flat roofs, or ground-mounted. Modern solar PV panels also tolerate partial shading better because arrays can be configured with multiple strings or optimisers.

Solar tiles need to be integrated with the roof structure. They work best on roofs that are to be replaced, or on new builder, where the tiles can form part of the roofing layer from the start.

If your roof is in poor condition, tiles may force an expensive reroof. If it’s in good condition and you prefer a less invasive install, panels are typically the most cost effective choice.

6. Which Lasts Longer and Which Needs More Maintenance?

While both technologies have long lifespans, solar panels are easier and cheaper to maintain or replace.

Solar panels have proven lifetimes of over 30 years and often carry warranties for more than 30 years on product and 30 years on performance. Because panels are modular, if one fails it can be swapped out without disturbing the roof covering.

Read this article to learn more about how long solar panels last.

Solar tiles aim for similar lifetimes, but their integrated nature can make maintenance or replacement more complex. If a single tile fails, replacing it may require more careful work to maintain weatherproofing and visual consistency. For any roof-integrated system, ensure the installer provides clear terms on waterproofing liability and long-term access for repairs.

Read this article to learn more about solar panel maintenance.

7. How Easy Is It to Repair, Replace, or Upgrade Later?

Short answer: solar panels are easier to repair and upgrade.

Adding more panels or swapping equipment (for example inverters or batteries) is straightforward with conventional systems.

Tiles, because they are built into the roof, can make retrofits trickier, though some BIPV systems have been designed with modular replacement in mind. If you think you might expand capacity later or want flexibility, panels are the safer bet.

8. Can I Use Batteries and Have Backup Power with Either Option?

Yes, both can work with battery storage and backup systems; panels have more established compatibility.

Both solar panels and solar tiles absorb DC electricity that is converted via inverters to usable electricity for your home.

Batteries and hybrid inverters are widely available and typically work with conventional panel systems. Many installers will size systems from day one for later battery addition.

For tiles, confirm that the chosen product is compatible with the inverters and battery systems you plan to use and that the installer can accommodate a hybrid setup.

For homeowners who want blackout resilience, discuss battery capacity, inverter backup output, and the practical limits of powering your home during an outage.

Read this article to learn more about how battery storage works.

9. How does each affect your home’s resale value and insurance?

A well-installed solar system that reduces running costs and comes with transferable warranties is attractive to buyers. Solar tiles may be a selling point for buyers who value curb appeal, while panels may appeal to buyers focused on long-term savings.

Make sure your installer provides documentation that you can pass to future owners and check with your insurer that your policy covers the new roof elements and electrical equipment.

10. Warranties and Guarantees: What To Look For

There are three things to confirm in any quote: product warranty (against manufacturing defects), performance warranty (guarantee of your panels’ performance over time) and workmanship guarantee (installation quality).

For solar tiles, workmanship and waterproofing assurances become particularly important because roof integration raises the stakes for leaks.

Ask for written warranty terms, find out whether warranties are backed locally, and check what happens if the manufacturer ceases trading. A good installer will explain these scenarios clearly.

11.Payback Time and Lifetime Value: What to Expect

The key drivers of payback are system cost, electricity generation, your household consumption profile, export rates and electricity prices. Because panels usually cost less per kW and often deliver higher output per square metre, they tend to reach payback sooner if your goal is financial return.

Tiles can still make financial sense, especially if they replace an old roof, but the economics are generally less favourable compared with conventional panels when measured purely in payback years per euro invested.

Read this article to learn more about payback periods.

12. A Compact Comparison

13. Decision Guides: Which Should You Choose?

Choose solar panels if:

• Your main priority is maximum electricity.
• Your roof has a good, unshaded south-facing area and doesn’t need replacing soon.
• You want the option to expand, add batteries later, or easily repair the system.

Choose solar tiles if:

• Aesthetics are a high priority.
• You’re reroofing anyway and want an integrated solution.
• You accept a higher up-front cost for a seamless look and are prepared for specialist warranties.

14. Practical Checklist: Before You Sign

• Book a site survey: confirm roof condition, orientation, shading and structural suitability.
• Ask for three detailed quotes that break down materials, labour, scaffolding, electrics and VAT.
• Request a predicted annual yield for your roof area and an explanation of assumptions.
• Check warranties: product, performance, and workmanship, get them in writing.
• Confirm installer accreditation, references and examples of local installations.
• Ask about battery compatibility and future upgrades.
• If considering tiles, ask how repairs or replacements are handled and who is responsible for waterproofing.
• Check with your local planning authority if your home is a protected structure.
• Compare full project timelines and on-site disruption plans.
• Retain all documentation for future buyers and your insurer.

15. Final Thoughts

There is no single “better” answer that fits every Irish home.

If your goal is cost-effective electricity generation and flexibility, solar panels are the most proven and practical choice for most homeowners.

If you’re re-roofing, or hoping to improve the look of your roof while investing more, solar tiles may be an attractive option.

The correct next step is a properly executed site survey and at least three comparable quotes. When you compare, insist the figures and assumptions are clear so you can weigh appearance, cost, lifetime value and disruption. That way you’ll end up with the option that best suits both your house and your priorities.

Ready to Take the Next Step?

If you’re thinking installing solar PV panels, we can help make the process stress-free. Complete the form below to get a free home solar quote and consultation.